top of page

CHOOSE!

Writer: stphilipseasthampt
stphilipseasthampt
Nov 9
7 min read

A sermon given on Sunday, November 8, 2026

by the Rt. Rev. Alan M. Gates, Bridge Pastor


One of my all-time favorite films is Kenneth Branagh’s version of Shakespeare’s Henry V.  Its climax is the famous St Crispin’s Day oration.  Henry’s outnumbered soldiers are in their embattled encampment as dawn breaks.  There the king delivers one of the most rousing speeches in all of literary history. 

We few, we happy few, we band of brothers;for he to-day that sheds his blood with me shall be my brother; …and gentlemen in England now a-bedshall think themselves accursed they were not here,and hold their manhoods cheap while any speaksthat fought with us upon Saint Crispin's day.   [Act IV, Scene 3]

 

The future is clouded.  The challenges are great.  The spirit wavers.  And Henry asks, “Will you stay with me?”  It is a moment to choose.

 

Our reading this morning from the very last chapter of the Book of Joshua [24:1-3,14-25] is a pivotal moment in Hebrew Scripture.  Let’s set the scene.  Joshua, you recall, was Moses’s right-hand man in the wilderness after the Exodus.  When Moses died, it was Joshua whom God anointed to bring the Hebrews into the Promised Land.  It was Joshua who led in battle at places like Jericho.  It was Joshua who divided their new territory among the Twelve Tribes of Israel.

 

In today’s episode, Joshua has gathered all God’s people at Shechem – a place laden with historic significance.  Shechem was where, generations ago, Abram had heard God’s promise to call forth a chosen people.  Shechem was where Abraham’s grandson Jacob and his household had re-committed to their God, burying all the foreign idols that had gradually become familiar and accepted.  Shechem had been one of Joshua’s first stops as the Israelites entered the Promised Land. So Shechem was a place for covenant renewal.

 

In today’s reading, Joshua knows he is soon to die.  He summons all the people to  Shechem to renew their covenant with God once again.  Joshua reminds them of the whole long story of God’s faithfulness to them.  He reminds them that at times their ancestors have strayed and served other gods.  Finally, he speaks these famous words: 

Now therefore revere the Lord, and serve him in sincerity and faithfulness; put away the gods that your ancestors served beyond the River and in Egypt, and serve the Lord.  … Choose this day whom you will serve … but as for me and my household, we will serve the Lord.  [Joshua 24:14-15]

 

The people answer, “Far be it from us that we should forsake the Lord.”  But Joshua pushes back.  Maybe their answer is a little too quick, too rote, too facile.  He reminds them this is not an easy promise, that they have strayed before.  But the people make their affirmation:  “The Lord our God we will serve.”  Their covenant is renewed.

 

It would be hard to overstate the significance of this moment.  Joshua has been the people’s leader for decades during a key time of transition from wandering tribe to nationhood.  He is about to be taken from them. The future is clouded.  The challenges are great.  The spirit wavers.  And through God’s mouthpiece God asks, “Whom then will you serve?”  It is a moment to choose.

 

I expect that you and I have our own such moments: St. Crispin’s Day moments, when we are afraid and overwhelmed by the odds; Shechem moments, when we are reminded that God is good, yet life is hard, and we are challenged to choose faith.  We might even think of the disciples on Maundy Thursday as Jesus made clear his departure was imminent.  These are moments when either the demands or the sheer incomprehensibility of our faith can be more challenging than comforting.  There are, frankly, many things which present themselves as stumbling blocks to our faith, as they did to Henry’s soldiers, to the Israelites, and to Jesus’s disciples.

 

Fear is a stumbling block.  My fears and anxieties, large and small, do not simply melt away by some facile recitation of Jesus’ injunction not to worry but only to “consider the lilies.”  Do yours?

 

Seemingly impossible demands are a stumbling block.  Some of Christ’s teachings like “turn the other cheek,” “love your enemy,” or “let the last be first” seem so illogical, sometimes even offensive.  And taking these injunctions seriously is apt to make other people mad.  We wonder how we are supposed to follow them – don’t we?

 

Inattention is another stumbling block.  Lots of the time I’m not acting in willful disobedience.  I’m just so wrapped up going about my business that I don’t give a thought to what religious principles I should be applying at a given moment.

 

Incomprehension is another stumbling block.  The Israelites couldn’t imagine why God dropped them into a desert after delivering them from slavery.  Jesus’ disciples couldn’t make out his words at the Last Supper:  “Bread of heaven … drink my blood … live forever …”  What in the world?

 

So yes, each of us has our own occasions or chapters of life in which arise stumbling blocks to our faith: fear, irrational demands, inattention, or incomprehension.  In these moments we, too, are faced with the need to make a choice.  The future is clouded.  The challenges are great.  The spirit wavers.  And God asks, “Whom then will you serve?”  It is a moment to choose.

 

Now, why in the world is that parable in today’s Gospel reading from Matthew [25:1-13] linked today with Joshua?  Here we have these ten maidens chosen to provide an escort for the bridegroom at an evening wedding feast.  But there is a delay.  (I mean, of course there is a delay!  Raise your hand if you have ever been to a wedding that started on time.  I keep a log of weddings I have performed, which tells me I have officiated at 89 weddings.  I do not think a single one of them started on time!)  So by the time the bridegroom shows up five of the maidens are out of lamp oil.  They demand some from the five who planned ahead; those five refuse; and by the time the empty-tankers get back from Aubuchon with more oil, it’s too late.

 

It’s always important to know what a parable is NOT about.  The parable of Laborers in the Vineyard (the one where everyone gets paid the same whether they worked all day or an hour) is not about fair labor practices; it’s about grace.  The parable of the Good Shepherd (where the shepherd leaves 99 sheep vulnerable to predators in order to find one that’s lost) is not about best farming practices; it’s about being known and loved.  And this parable is not about whether or not we should share with others in need.  The Good Samaritan is that parable.  We have plenty of clear commands from Jesus to care for those in need. 

 

What this parable is about is choosing to be disciples of Christ, and accepting that when we choose this discipleship, it will make demands upon us.  The distress of those five maidens finding themselves left out is a way of pointing to the wisdom of the other five.  The wise maidens have accepted an invitation to have a role in the wedding.  But that choice has implications.  As one commenter has put it:

“This is a wedding party, but they are not merely guests; they are participants with roles and responsibilities. The same is so for being a follower of God: we are not spectators who can just rub our lamps and tell the genie what we need. God asks us … to be involved and present and aware of the needs of the world around us. We cannot look to others to do the life of faith for us.  That’s what the foolish do. …  [T]hose who are wise have devoted themselves to being responsible for what God has asked of them.”  [Chelsea Harmon - Matthew 25:1-13 - Center for Excellence in Preaching]

I think the lectionary has paired this Gospel with the reading from Joshua because the parable, too, is about choosing whom we will serve.

 

Now, listen:  Saying goodbye to a long-time leader.  A future that is unpredictable.  Challenges that are great. … People of St. Philip’s, does any of that sound familiar?  Well then, you too are at a moment where you are invited to “choose this day whom you will serve.”

 

I’ll tell you how it looks to me.  With your Power Packs ministry, your Take & Eat commitment, your new social justice committee, and that growing food drive table at the back of the church, I see a congregation that chooses to serve God by loving your neighbor.

 

With your care for one another through prayers, visits, and the best coffee hours in Western Massachusetts (!), I see a congregation that chooses Christian community over modern isolation. 

 

With your faithfulness to worship, offering praise and prayers and song (even on Sundays when there is no priest present), and your attention to the Word, I see a congregation that chooses to be disciples of Christ.

 

Good for you.  Keep it up!  For like the Israelites, who wandered and got discouraged and forgot and let foreign gods slip into their midst – we have to keep on choosing.  Like Jesus’ disciples who sometimes fell asleep, and sometimes misunderstood, and sometimes got scared and denied him – we have to keep on choosing.  It’s not once-and-for-ever.  It’s again and again and again.

 

Dear friends, St. Philip’s is your Shechem.  This place is a place to return to again and again to renew our covenant to be disciples of Christ, and to receive nourishment to do just that.  I do not know what stumbling blocks to faith are present in your life these days.  But whatever they are, choose Christ.

In the face of all life’s distractions, choose to listen.

In the face of incomprehension, choose to believe.

In the face of seemingly illogical demands of faith, choose to risk.

In the face of fear, choose to trust.

In Jesus’ Name, Amen.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
USE IT OR LOSE IT

A sermon given on Sunday, November 15, 2026 by the Rt. Rev. Alan M. Gates, Bridge Pastor One of the things that happens when you move is that you end up going through boxes of old stuff. So it was th

 
 
 
LIGHTING UP OUR SKIES

A sermon given on Sunday, November 1, 2026 by the Rt. Rev. Alan M. Gates, Bridge Pastor Some years ago, on All Souls Day I stood at a grave in Des Plaines, Illinois, and learned the story of a man I h

 
 
 
YEAR A-PENTECOST XXII

A sermon given on Sunday, October 25, 2026 by Sr. Helen Agnes, SSM As someone who is not a native New Englander, the changing of seasons has always felt like a special time for me. Growing up in Flori

 
 
 

Comments


chm_stphilipseasthampton_index1a_03.png

126 Main Street
Easthampton, MA 01027

 

413-527-0862


stphilipseasthampton@gmail.com

The Right Rev. Miguelina Howell
Bishop of Western Massachusetts

​

The Rt. Rev. Alan Gates, Bridge Pastor

​

Karen Banta, Organist & Choir Director

​

Lesa Sweigart, Parish Administrator

 

Chip Secco, Sexton

  • White Instagram Icon
  • White YouTube Icon
  • White Facebook Icon
bottom of page